On the way home from watching a really crappy show today, Brian and I struck up a rather heated conversation over church structure and organisation. Was there a need for a hierarchical structure in church? Is it even biblical to have such a structure?
In many churches around the world, the way church is being run is likened very much to a business. With the clergy being akin to CEOs. In some cases, it is even likened to an army, with ranks and officers etc.
Though both of these forms of structure have their advantages, the basis of the structure may be a little skewed.
Biblically, we know that God gives structure. The family is in itself a hierarchical structure, the nation of Israel was a kingdom with God (initially) as their King and later the whole line of kings beginning with Saul. The early church in Acts shows evidence of the church elders and the apostles as leaders of the church. So hierarchical structure is definitely from God and so I itself it is good. What then should be the basis of the structure?
Why should I defer to your judgment? Why should I listen to what you say? What right do I have to tell you what to do? The basis of all church structure should be accountability. Not rank. Not seniority.
In the family, the husband is the leader because he is accountable to God for his family. He leads his wife and she is accountable to him for her actions. The children are accountable to their parents and are so of a 'lower rank' to them. The kings of Israel were accountable to God for the nation and the apostles were leaders because they were accountable for the rest of the body of Christ.
Church structure should be borne out of accountability. At Praise Fellowship, my prayer triplet members are accountable to me as their prayer triplet leader. I am accountable to my cell leader and she is accountable to the zone supervisor, who is in turn accountable to Pastor. The leader is also accountable to the follower. Accountable to lead. I am willingly accountable to my cell leader because of the relationship that we have forged over the past years.
So, hierarchy, organisation and structure are needed in church for the smooth running of events. This should be based on a structure for accountability and accountability is grown from a relationship with others.